Emberpage
My Sister's Husband Called Me by Her Name cover

My Sister's Husband Called Me by Her Name

Ongoing · 6 chapters · about 9,300 words

Suspense Mystery Betrayal Drama Hidden Identity

At my sister's memorial, her widower called me by her name — and he wasn't confused. Robin has been dead for eight years.

We buried my sister eight years after she disappeared, in a coffin with nothing in it. Her husband stood at the front of the Legion hall and thanked everyone for coming. Then, in the kitchen, with his hand on my wrist and the coffee urn ticking behind us, he said, "Robin. Don't." Everybody heard it. Everybody decided not to. My mother said he'd had a long day. My brother said I was making a thing out of nothing, and he said it the way you say it to someone you've said it to before. That night Aaron texted me twice. The second one said: You didn't say anything back. Robin used to do that too. I have spent eight years being handled — softly, patiently, by every person who loves me — and it took one word in a church kitchen to make me understand why. They aren't being gentle with me because I lost my sister. They're being gentle with me because of what they think I did to her. And now I've charged my old phone, and the last message Robin ever sent me is not the one I remember.

Start chapter 1

3 of 6 chapters are free to read here.

How it begins

We buried my sister on the first Saturday in October, eight years after she died, in a plot that had been paid for since the spring.

There was nothing in the casket. I want to be honest about that up front, because a lot of what happened afterward turns on it. Robin's car was found at the north boat ramp at Cobb Reservoir on the tenth of September, eight years ago, with the keys in the cup holder and her phone under the passenger seat, and they dragged that water for eleven days and then for four more days in the spring, and they never found her. So on the first Saturday in October we put a closed box in the ground with a photograph inside it and her reading glasses, because my mother could not stand the idea of the box being empty, and my mother is a woman who will fill a thing.

The court had declared Robin dead in July. Aaron filed the petition in March, which was the first any of us heard that a petition was a thing that could be filed, and then in July a judge in Fairmount signed a paper, and then in August the insurance came through, and then in October we had a funeral.

That was the order. I want that written down somewhere.

The service was at St. Brigid's and the lunch was at the Legion hall on Route 12, because the Legion has the long tables and doesn't charge you for the kitchen. It was seventy-one degrees and gray. The gravel lot at the Legion is the kind that gets in your shoes, and I stood in it for two minutes after I parked, holding a casserole dish with HALLORAN written on masking tape on the bottom in my mother's handwriting, and I texted Wes.

Continue chapter 1

Chapters

  1. 1. Eight Years Late
  2. 2. The Younger One
  3. 3. We Decided to Believe You
  4. 4. A Name I Already Knew
  5. 5. Somebody Said It
  6. 6. Don't Say My Name