I Left the Don at the Altar. Six Years Later, He Found My Son. · Nadia Voss
Chapter 1: He Has His Father's Eyes
Six years ago I left Matteo Cassaro standing at the altar in front of three hundred guests.
I never told him why.
Tonight he walked into the diner where I pour coffee for eleven dollars an hour, and my son was sitting at the counter.
* * *
It was 9:40 on a Tuesday night in Amarillo, Texas. The dinner rush was over. Two truckers in the corner booth. Moths ticking against the front window.
And Leo, on the third stool from the end, coloring a stegosaurus purple.
He wasn't supposed to be there. His sitter had the flu. My boss said he could stay if he didn't touch the pie case. So he sat with his crayons and his chocolate milk, sneakers swinging, and every few minutes he told me something important about dinosaurs.
I was wiping down the coffee machine when my phone buzzed for the ninth time.
Joey.
My little brother had called at six that morning, crying so hard I could barely understand him.
Nina, he sold it. The pawnshop guy sold my paper. To some people back east.
Eighty-six thousand dollars. That's what Joey owed the man who ran the pawnshop on Amarillo Boulevard. Forty thousand he borrowed. The rest was what happens when you borrow from a man like that.
Back east. I'd told myself all day that it meant nothing. East was a big place.
I didn't answer the ninth call. I turned the phone face down.
Then the bell over the door rang.
He came in alone.
Black suit. White shirt open at the collar. Dark hair cut shorter than I remembered. A thin white scar through his left eyebrow that hadn't been there six years ago.
And gray eyes. That pale, cold gray, like a winter sky over the harbor.
The rag fell out of my hand.
No. No, no, no.
He walked to the counter and sat down two stools away from my son. He looked at me like he'd seen me yesterday.
"Coffee," he said. "Black."
My hands knew how to do it even if the rest of me didn't. I took a cup. I poured. Coffee slopped over the rim into the saucer.
He didn't touch it.
"Nina."
Nobody had said my name like that in six years. Here I was Nina Ross. Nina Ross had a Texas driver's license, a 2009 Corolla and a son.
Nina Russo had been engaged to the heir of the most feared family in Baltimore.
"You have the wrong person," I said.
He reached into his jacket and laid a folded paper on the counter. He smoothed it flat with two fingers.
I knew what it was before I read it. Joey's name. Joey's signature, the loopy one he'd had since third grade. And the number. $86,000.
"Your brother owes me," Matteo said.
My heart was hammering so hard it hurt.
"I'll pay it." It came out too fast. "All of it. I just need time."
"How much do you make here?"
I didn't answer.
"How much, Nina?"
"Eleven an hour. Plus tips."
He looked at the paper. Then at me. He didn't say what we both knew. I would be dead before I paid that off.
How did he find us? How long has he known?
"Mommy." Leo leaned over the counter and tugged my sleeve. "Mommy, the green one rolled. I need the green one."
Everything in me went cold.
Matteo turned his head.
He looked at Leo for the first time.
I watched it happen. I watched him see the dark hair curling at the back of the neck. The stubborn chin. And the eyes.
Leo's eyes aren't mine. Mine are brown. Leo's are gray, that strange pale gray I have only ever seen in one family. The same gray that was looking at him right now.
Matteo went completely still.
Leo, who was five and afraid of nothing, looked right back.
"You're by my green crayon," he said.
Matteo looked down. The green crayon was by his elbow. He picked it up and held it out.
Leo took it. "Thank you." Then he tilted his head. "Your eyes are like mine."
"Leo." My voice cracked. "Go sit in the back office. Now, baby."
"But my dinosaur—"
"Now."
He slid off the stool and went, dragging his feet, looking back over his shoulder the whole way. The kitchen door swung shut behind him.
Silence.
The truckers had stopped talking. Outside the window, under the parking lot light, a black SUV sat with its engine running. Two men in the front seat. Of course he hadn't come alone. He never needed anyone to see them.
Matteo didn't look at me. He looked at the kitchen door.
"How old is he?"
"Four."
It was out before I could think. A stupid lie. A desperate one.
"One rule, Nina." His voice didn't rise at all. "You don't lie to me. Not anymore. How old?"
I gripped the edge of the counter. Don't cry. Don't you dare cry in front of him.
"Five," I whispered.
I didn't have to say the rest. He could count.
Six years ago in June, I had been his fiancée for eleven months. Six years ago in June, I was seven weeks pregnant, and I hadn't told him.
I hadn't told anyone.
A muscle moved in his jaw. For one second I saw something in his face that looked like pain. Then it was gone, and there was only stone.
"You ran," he said quietly. "With my son."
"He's not—"
"Don't."
One word. It shut my mouth like a hand.
He stood. He tucked a hundred-dollar bill under the full cup of coffee.
"Your shift ends at ten."
He knows when my shift ends.
"We'll talk at your apartment. 14B. Hughes Street."
He knows where I live.
"You can't just walk in here and—"
He leaned across the counter. Close. Close enough that I smelled him, cedar and cold air, the smell I used to fall asleep in. My body remembered it before my mind could stop it.
Shame burned through me.
"Six years," he said, very low. "I looked for you for six years. I'm not asking."
Then he walked out, and the bell rang behind him like nothing had happened.
My knees gave out. I sat down on the floor behind the counter, between the dropped straws and the sugar packets, and pressed both hands over my mouth.
He didn't know why I ran.
He could never know.
Because if Matteo Cassaro ever found out what I heard outside his father's study the night before our wedding, I wouldn't be the only one who disappeared.
Leo would never be safe again.
I got up. I washed my face in the bathroom sink. I counted my tips. Two hundred and twelve dollars.
A car with half a tank. A son. A spare key to Joey's place.
I had run once, with nothing but a bag and a secret. I could do it again.
At 9:52 I carried Leo out the back door, half asleep, his dinosaur page crushed against my chest. The back lot was dark. My Corolla was where I'd left it, under the broken light by the dumpster.
Matteo Cassaro was leaning against the driver's door.
He didn't move. He looked at me, then at the sleeping boy in my arms, then back at me.
"You ran once," he said. "You don't get twice."