I Left the Don at the Altar. Six Years Later, He Found My Son. · Nadia Voss
Chapter 2: His Terms
Matteo Cassaro carried my son up the stairs to my apartment like he had been doing it all his life.
I didn't let him. I want that on the record. I held on to Leo until my arms shook, and Matteo stood at the bottom of the stairs and waited, and when I stumbled on the third step he took him out of my arms without a word.
Leo didn't even wake up. He just turned his face into the black jacket and sighed.
Something cracked inside my chest.
He's never been held by his father. Not once. And he fits.
I unlocked the door. Matteo walked in and looked at everything.
The couch with the blanket over the hole. The kitchen table with one short leg. Leo's drawings taped to the fridge. The cot in the corner of my bedroom, with the dinosaur sheets I'd bought at Goodwill and washed three times.
He laid Leo down on it. He pulled the blanket up to his chin. His hand stayed on the blanket for a second longer than it needed to.
Then he came back to the kitchen and sat down at my table. The chair creaked under him. He looked too big for it. Too big for this whole place.
I stayed by the sink, as far away as the room allowed.
"Why," he said.
Just that.
"I didn't want to marry you."
"That's a lie."
"I was twenty-one. I panicked."
"You left the dress on the bed." He said it flatly, like reading a list. "Shoes on the floor. Ring on top of the dress, in the middle. You took your father's car and four thousand dollars from his safe. You were on I-70 by eight." He looked at me. "That's not panic, Nina. That's a plan."
My throat closed.
He knew all of it. The ring. The safe. The highway.
Of course he does. He's a Cassaro. They always know.
"It doesn't matter why," I said.
"It matters to me."
"It's been six years."
"Six years, two months and nine days."
The way he said it made my eyes burn. I turned and filled a glass of water I didn't want, so he couldn't see my face.
"You know your father died," he said behind me.
The glass stopped halfway to my mouth.
I knew. I'd found out at a motel in Ohio, on a library computer, three weeks after I ran. A car fire on a road outside Baltimore. Accountant Salvatore Russo, 52. Four lines. No photo.
I had thrown up in the library bathroom and then I had kept driving.
"I know," I whispered.
"Do you know why he died?"
I turned around.
He was watching me. Gray eyes, perfectly calm.
"Because you weren't there," he said.
The floor seemed to tilt.
He's telling me. He's sitting at my kitchen table and telling me to my face.
Everything I had heard that night came back in one cold rush. And for a second I couldn't breathe.
"Get out," I said.
He didn't move.
"Get out of my house, Matteo."
"This isn't a house." He glanced around once. "It's a room you hide in."
"It's my room. It's my life. You don't get to walk in after six years and—"
"You don't get to steal five of them."
His voice didn't rise. It didn't have to. Every word landed like a stone.
"He doesn't know my name," Matteo said. "He doesn't know he has a grandmother. He doesn't know where he's from. He's sleeping on a cot from a thrift store, and he thinks a stranger in a diner has eyes like his." He paused. "You did that."
Humiliation flooded my face, hot and total.
Because he was right. And I hated him for being right.
"I did it to keep him safe," I said.
"Safe from what?"
From you. From your family. From whatever your father was willing to do.
I said nothing.
Matteo stood up. He came around the table, slowly, and stopped in front of me. I backed up until the counter hit my spine.
"Here's how this goes," he said.
I lifted my chin. "There is no how this goes."
"My father's dead. Two years now. I run the family." He said it the way other men say they run a hardware store. "Your brother's paper is mine. Eighty-six thousand. I'll burn it."
"In exchange for what?"
"You come home. Both of you. He takes my name."
"And me?"
He looked down at me for a long moment.
"You owe me a wedding," he said.
The breath went out of me.
"You're insane."
"Thursday. Ten in the morning. There's a plane."
"I'm not getting on any plane. I'm not marrying you. I'm not taking my son into that house."
"Then I take you to court in Maryland." No anger. Just fact. "And you explain to a judge why you hid a child from his father for five years under a fake name. You'll lose, Nina. You know you'll lose."
I knew. I'd known from the second he walked into the diner.
"And your brother's paper goes back on the market," he added. "There are people who'd buy it who aren't me."
"Is that a threat?"
"It's the truth. You should try it."
I slapped him.
I didn't plan it. My hand just moved. The sound cracked through the tiny kitchen, and my palm stung, and his head turned an inch to the side.
He turned it back.
He caught my wrist. Not hard. His thumb rested right over my pulse, and I knew he could feel how fast it was going.
"I hate you," I whispered.
"No," he said. "You don't."
He was so close. His eyes dropped to my mouth. Six years, and my whole body still leaned toward him like he was gravity.
Don't. Don't you dare.
For one second I thought he would kiss me.
Then he let go of my wrist and stepped back.
"Thursday," he said. "Ten."
He went to the door. He stopped by the cot. Leo had kicked his blanket off. Matteo bent down and pulled it back over him, and I saw his hand hover over my son's dark hair without quite touching it.
Then he was gone.
I didn't sleep. I sat on the kitchen floor with my back against the cabinet and my phone in my hand and tried to think of one place in America he couldn't find us.
There wasn't one.
At seven, Leo padded out in his dinosaur pajamas, rubbing his eyes.
"Mommy, why are you on the floor?"
"I'm just tired, baby."
He climbed into my lap. He smelled like sleep and crayons.
"Mommy. The man with my eyes was here last night."
My heart stopped. "You were asleep."
"I woke up when he fixed my blanket. I asked him if he's my dad."
I couldn't speak.
"He said ask your mommy." Leo uncurled his fist. Something was in it, a white card, bent from being slept on. "And he said if you try to go away, I should give you this."
I took it.
One side had a phone number. Nothing else.
On the back, in handwriting I would have known anywhere, five words:
Don't run. They're watching you.